Scholarly differences
The difference is about non-intoxicating alcohol formed by fermentation. IslamQA divides fermented drinks into those that intoxicate in large amounts, which are khamr and forbidden in any amount, and those whose alcohol is so small that no quantity intoxicates, which are Halal; it puts kefir in the second group.
IslamWeb applies the hadith 'Whatever causes intoxication when taken in a large quantity is also forbidden to take in small quantities' to any proven alcohol in kefir. LPPOM MUI, citing MUI fatwa 10/2018, treats fermented foods containing alcohol as Halal if the process uses nothing forbidden and they are harmless.
What decides the answer
-
Kefir that does not intoxicate in any amount
Halal per IslamQA and MUI -
Kefir with any proven alcohol
not permitted per IslamWeb -
Kefir drinks with added alcohol
not Halal
How to verify
- UK kefir drinks such as Biotiful and Yeo Valley list only milk fermented with live kefir cultures.
- Neither lists an alcohol content; fermentation alcohol isn't declared on the label.
- Decide by your scholar's view on non-intoxicating fermentation alcohol.
- Water kefir and flavoured kefirs are separate products; read their lists.
Quick checks
- Milk fermented with kefir grains.
- Yeasts make a little alcohol.
- IslamQA and MUI permit; IslamWeb does not.
Why this ruling
Kefir is a fermented milk drink from the Caucasus, now sold in UK supermarkets. Its culture includes yeasts as well as bacteria, and that's where the Halal question comes from.
What's in it
UK kefir drinks list very little: Biotiful's is pasteurised cow's milk fermented with live kefir cultures,[4] and Yeo Valley's is organic milk fermented the same way.[5] The yeasts in kefir grains produce carbon dioxide and a small amount of ethanol. IslamQA's answer puts it at about 0.1 to 0.5% in normal fermentation, rising to as much as 3% depending on preparation.[1] Labels don't state it.
Permitted: IslamQA and MUI
IslamQA divides fermented drinks into two kinds: those that intoxicate if drunk in quantity, which are khamr, and those whose alcohol is so slight that no amount intoxicates, which are Halal. It places kefir in the second group.[1] An LPPOM MUI article, applying Indonesia's 2018 fatwa, says fermented foods containing alcohol are Halal if nothing forbidden is used and they are harmless.[3]
Not permitted: IslamWeb
IslamWeb answers that if kefir is proven to contain alcohol, "it is not permissible to get benefit from it, even if the percentage of alcohol is little", citing the hadith that whatever intoxicates in large amounts is forbidden in small amounts.[2] The same split appears for kombucha and non-alcoholic beer. Ordinary yogurt, made with bacteria alone, doesn't raise it.
Where you'll find it
- Fermented milk drink
- Kefir yogurt
- Smoothies and overnight oats
Frequently asked questions
Is kefir Halal?
How much alcohol is in kefir?
Is kefir yogurt Halal?
Sources
Named Islamic, certifier, manufacturer, and regulatory sources used on this page. Inline markers like [1] jump here. Retrieval dates show when we last checked the live URL. Editorial methodology.
Islamic / scriptural
-
Ruling on drinking kefir (184243)
IslamQA Retrieved
Alcohol in kefir 'varies... between 0.1 and 0.5% of the volume, and may reach as much as 3%'. Drinks whose alcohol 'is very small, in such a way that it will not cause intoxication no matter how much a person drinks of it' are halal; kefir 'is not haraam... because the concentration of alcohol mentioned is small and does not make the drink cause intoxication'.
-
Ruling on fermented Kefir (Fatwa 199037)
IslamWeb Retrieved
'If it is proved that there is a percentage of alcohol in that drink, then it is not permissible to get benefit from it, even if the percentage of alcohol is little', citing 'Whatever causes intoxication when taken in a large quantity is also forbidden to take in small quantities' (Ahmad).
-
LPPOM MUI Retrieved
27 October 2019. Cites MUI Fatwa 10 of 2018: 'Fermented food products containing alcohol/ethanol are legally halal, as long as the process does not use illicit substances and if medically harmless.'
Manufacturer / product
-
Open Food Facts Retrieved
Pasteurised cow's milk fermented with live kefir cultures (Bifidobacterium, Lactobacillus acidophilus, L. plantarum, L. casei, L. rhamnosus). Label recorded: vegetarian.
-
People also check
Related ingredients and products for this item.



