isithalal.food

Corrections

How the isithalal.food Editorial Team fixes errors

Last updated 30 September 2026

What we correct

  • Wrong or outdated verdicts (Halal, Haram, Halal if verified, Market-dependent, Scholarly difference) or conditions.
  • Broken, mislabelled, or superseded manufacturer and certifier links.
  • Missing or stale retrieval dates and market-panel last-checked dates.
  • Arabic/English twin mismatches on the same food topic.
  • Legacy wording that still says Uncertain or mashbooh where the page should use an actionable status.

How to report

Use the contact form. Include the page URL, a short description of the issue, and a primary source link when available. Choose topic “Correction / source update.” If you have evidence about a specific product, such as an ingredient list, a certificate or the maker's page, use the product evidence form below.

Send product evidence

Tell us which product, bought where, and send the evidence: a link to the maker's page or the certifier's register, a photo of the ingredient list, or the Halal certificate. Recipes change by country and over time, so the market and the barcode help us check the same product.

We read every submission, but a submission never changes a verdict by itself. The Editorial Team checks the evidence against the product and market, cites it on the page with the date we checked it, and lists any material change in the log below.

Evidence: send at least one

What happens next

  1. The Editorial Team checks the claim against named sources.
  2. We update the page (and the Arabic version when relevant), refresh retrieval dates, and update the Last reviewed date.
  3. Material fixes show on the page via the Last reviewed date and the Sources or market evidence blocks, and are listed in the corrections log below.

Corrections log

Material changes to verdicts and evidence, newest first. Each entry names the page, what changed and why. Minor copy edits are not listed. The log starts on 30 September 2026.

  • · Verdict changed

    Chick-fil-A: Halal if verified → Haram

    Chick-fil-A's own FAQ says none of its menu items meet Halal standards. Other chains that say the same (Prezzo, Zizzi, Toby Carvery, Miller & Carter) are Haram here, so Chick-fil-A now is too. Its UK restaurants, now covered on the page, make no Halal claim.

  • · Verdict changed

    Dave's Hot Chicken: Halal if verified → Market-dependent

    The page covered only the US and Canada. Dave's UK FAQ says all the chicken in its restaurants is Halal, from certified suppliers and pre-stunned, while its kitchens don't follow Halal procedures. The page now has UK and US panels.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Mentos

    Gelatin claim corrected. The page said chewy Mentos in Western markets contain gelatin and that the classic roll always does. Pack records updated in 2026 for the UK, the US and Europe list no gelatin (gellan, cellulose and arabic gums instead). The page now says so, and names the emulsifiers (sucrose esters, and mono- and diglycerides in the US) as the open question; the status stays Halal if verified.

  • · Evidence corrected

    KFC

    Canada corrected. The page said KFC Canada had no Halal programme. KFC Canada said that from 15 May 2024 all chicken at its Ontario restaurants, except Thunder Bay and Ottawa, is Halal-certified; the page now has a Canada panel (Halal if verified) citing that notice as reported by NOW Toronto and Daily Hive, and still notes CBC Marketplace's findings.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Shellfish

    Verdict unchanged (Scholarly difference). The table said crustaceans including crab are permitted in many Shafi'i readings; the stronger Shafi'i view forbids crab. It now says so, and that Hanafi scholars differ on shrimp, with a source.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Carmine (E120)

    Verdict unchanged (Scholarly difference). The page said Maliki scholars allow carmine because the school permits insects. The Maliki school permits insects only when they are killed in order to be eaten, and a Maliki answer (SeekersGuidance, Shaykh Rami Nsour) finds that carmine, as it is made, does not meet that condition. The permissive side is Jordan's Iftaa' Department and Indonesia's MUI, with conditions.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Crab

    Verdict unchanged (Scholarly difference). The page said the Shafi'i school permits crab. The IslamWeb fatwa it cites says the Shafi'i school has two views and the stronger one forbids crab (al-Nawawi: "the frog and the crab are forbidden"); the Maliki and Hanbali schools permit it. The page now says so.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Oreos

    Verdict unchanged. The page said Oreo emulsifiers are often mono- and diglycerides; classic EU packs list soya and sunflower lecithin. A table still used the older Market-dependent label for uncertified Oreos; it now says Halal if verified, matching the country panels.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Toblerone

    Verdict unchanged. The page said uncertified bars raised an E471 emulsifier question. Current UK, US and EU packs list soya lecithin as the emulsifier, with no E471 and no gelatin, so the page now names the flavouring as the one unaudited point and cites each pack.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Twix

    Verdict unchanged. The US and UK panels already showed Halal if verified, but their text still called the US answer Market-dependent, an older label. The text now matches the badge, and three near-identical FAQs are merged into one.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Snickers

    Verdict unchanged. An FAQ said the US verdict was Market-dependent while the US panel showed Halal if verified; it now says Halal if verified. A duplicate FAQ is removed.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Milky Way

    Verdict unchanged. The US and UK panel text named Market-dependent while their badges showed Halal if verified; the text now matches. A duplicate FAQ is removed.

  • · Evidence corrected

    CAVA (restaurant)

    Verdict unchanged (Halal if verified). We had said CAVA published no Halal statement; its own X account said in 2017 that the meat in its braised lamb is certified Halal, and in 2020 that its spicy lamb meatballs are not. The page now cites both.

  • · Evidence corrected

    M&M's

    The UK verdict is now Haram, from Halal if verified. The official M&M's UK account said in 2019 that no variety is suitable for a Halal diet, and UK peanut and crispy packs list carmine (E120). Other markets are unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Wingstop

    Verdict unchanged (Market-dependent). The UK section now cites Wingstop UK's own FAQ, which says its Halal chickens are stunned before slaughter, instead of the US homepage.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Vinegar

    New section on vinegar inside other foods: accepted in bought products, as JAKIM-certified mayonnaise shows, except a label that says wine vinegar. Malaysia's 2006 fatwa is now scoped to wine vinegar.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Ketchup

    Verdict unchanged (Halal). The page had cited IslamQA 2283 as permitting deliberately made vinegar, which it does not; it now cites the Shafi'i, IslamQA 191176 and JAKIM evidence for vinegar in bought food.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Mayonnaise

    Verdict unchanged (Halal). The vinegar is now sourced to the Shafi'i and IslamQA rulings on commercial vinegar and to JAKIM's certification of Kewpie mayonnaise.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Mustard

    Verdict unchanged (Halal) for yellow mustard. Dijon made with wine vinegar is now marked a scholarly difference instead of Halal.

  • · Verdict changed

    Taurine: Halal → Halal if verified

    Only Red Bull publishes that its taurine is synthetic. For other brands the source needs the maker's statement or a Halal certificate.

  • · Verdict changed

    Monster Energy: Halal → Halal if verified

    The Darul Iftaa Birmingham fatwa covers the original drink's listed ingredients only. Other lines differ, and the Beast Unleashed line is alcoholic.

  • · Verdict changed

    Eel: Halal if verified → Scholarly difference

    The eel itself changes status by school: Hanafi rulings permit it as a fish; Ja'fari rulings require scales. The unagi glaze is a separate check.

  • · Verdict changed

    Catfish: Halal → Scholarly difference

    Sunni rulings treat catfish as a fish, but Ja'fari rulings, including Sayyid al-Sistani's, forbid fish without scales.

  • · Verdict changed

    Caviar: Halal → Scholarly difference

    Sturgeon is disputed: Sunni rulings permit it; some Ja'fari references exclude it, while Ayatollah Khomeini ruled sturgeon with scales near the tail halal in 1983. Salmon and trout roe stay Halal.

  • · Verdict changed

    Horse Meat: Halal → Halal if verified

    Horse is a permitted species for most scholars, but like beef and lamb the meat needs Islamic slaughter.

  • · Verdict changed

    Vinegar: Halal → Scholarly difference

    Commercial vinegar is made on purpose from an alcoholic liquid, and fatwa bodies split: the Hanafi school and Indonesia's MUI permit it; the classical Shafi'i rule and Malaysia's National Fatwa Committee do not.

  • · Verdict changed

    Malt Vinegar: Halal if verified → Scholarly difference

    Malt vinegar is judged like every other deliberately made vinegar; see Vinegar.

  • · Verdict changed

    Balsamic Vinegar: Halal → Scholarly difference

    Commercial balsamic is deliberately made vinegar, which fatwa bodies split on; see Vinegar.

  • · Verdict changed

    Apple Cider Vinegar: Halal → Scholarly difference

    Cider vinegar starts as cider and is judged like every other deliberately made vinegar; see Vinegar.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Chick-fil-A

    Now cites Chick-fil-A's own FAQ: none of its menu items meet Halal standards. Unsourced claims about shared oil and franchises were removed.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Marmite

    Scoped to the UK range, which Marmite says the Halal Food Authority certifies; the dispute over brewer's yeast extract is now named.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Mineral colours (calcium carbonate, iron oxides, aluminium, silver, gold)

    The rulings on eating gold and silver leaf are now credited to IslamWeb and Darul Iftaa Mahmudiyyah, with their conditions.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Tea

    Scoped to plain tea and sourced to named Shafi'i and Hanafi rulings; unsourced consensus claims were removed.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Red Bull

    Unsourced certifier claims replaced by two named fatwas and Red Bull's own taurine statement.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Lamb

    HMC's no-stunning rule is credited to HMC only; unsourced market claims were removed.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Haggis

    Rewritten around a maker's actual ingredient lists; 'only if labelled Halal' was replaced, since home-made haggis with Halal meat is Halal.

  • · Evidence corrected

    CAVA (restaurant)

    Now cites CAVA's 2025 annual report, and no longer infers a negative from a blocked website.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Red Wine Vinegar

    Verdict unchanged (Scholarly difference) but now sourced to the national fatwa bodies on both sides; see Vinegar.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Spirit Vinegar

    Verdict unchanged (Scholarly difference) but now sourced to the national fatwa bodies on both sides; see Vinegar.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Beef Gelatin

    Now sets out the named dispute over gelatin from cattle not slaughtered Islamically.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Chorizo

    Now names a certified Halal beef chorizo alongside the traditional pork product.

Related

Report a correction Methodology