Corrections

How the isithalal.food Editorial Team fixes errors

Last updated 30 September 2026

What we correct

  • Wrong or outdated verdicts (Halal, Haram, Halal if verified, Market-dependent, Scholarly difference) or conditions.
  • Broken, mislabelled, or superseded manufacturer and certifier links.
  • Missing or stale retrieval dates and market-panel last-checked dates.
  • Arabic/English twin mismatches on the same food topic.
  • Legacy wording that still says Uncertain or mashbooh where the page should use an actionable status.

How to report

Use the contact form. Include the page URL, a short description of the issue, and a primary source link when available. Choose topic “Correction / source update.” If you have evidence about a specific product, such as an ingredient list, a certificate or the maker's page, use the product evidence form below.

Send product evidence

Tell us which product, bought where, and send the evidence: a link to the maker's page or the certifier's register, a photo of the ingredient list, or the Halal certificate. Recipes change by country and over time, so the market and the barcode help us check the same product.

We read every submission, but a submission never changes a verdict by itself. The Editorial Team checks the evidence against the product and market, cites it on the page with the date we checked it, and lists any material change in the log below.

Evidence: send at least one

What happens next

  1. The Editorial Team checks the claim against named sources.
  2. We update the page (and the Arabic version when relevant), refresh retrieval dates, and update the Last reviewed date.
  3. Material fixes show on the page via the Last reviewed date and the Sources or market evidence blocks, and are listed in the corrections log below.

Corrections log

Material changes to verdicts and evidence, newest first. Each entry names the page, what changed and why. Minor copy edits are not listed. The log starts on 30 September 2026.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Hot dogs

    The page said natural hot-dog casings can be hog intestine, that flavourings can use alcohol-based carriers, and that many American hot dogs list pork as the main ingredient. We found no source for these. Wikipedia's hot dog article says traditional natural casing is sheep intestine and hot dogs are made from pork, beef, chicken, turkey or a mix; the page now says that and cites it. The verdict (Halal if verified) is unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Sugar

    The page said most scholars and Halal certifiers do not treat bone-char filtration as making sugar Haram, and that beet, organic and most European and Asian sugar never touch bone char. We found no source for either claim. The page now cites two rulings: IslamQA holds that bone char burned completely into charcoal or ash is pure and does not affect the sugar, and Darul Ifta Birmingham accepts char from cattle bones but not from pig bones. The verdict (Halal) is unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Oyster sauce

    The page said some Hanafi muftis permit oyster sauce because the oyster extract is a small, cooked fraction. We found no source for that. Mufti Ebrahim Desai's Hanafi answer on seafood in the four schools names oyster extract as not permissible for Hanafis. The page now says so and cites it. The verdict (scholars differ) is unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Fruit Pastilles

    The page said Nestlé moved the whole Rowntree's Fruit Pastilles range to a gelatine-free, vegan recipe. Nestlé's own pages show that holds for the core range only: the lolly-shaped Fruit Pastilles Lollies sweets list gelatine, and Nestlé says it uses pork gelatine in Rowntree's Lollies products. The page now names that exception and marks those sweets Haram. The verdict for the core Fruit Pastilles is unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Lilydale

    The page cited Lilydale's August 2025 Halal list, which included Wing Nibbles in Vietnamese flavour. Lilydale's current list, updated October 2025, no longer includes them, and adds a freezer range, more chilled lines and seasoned whole birds. The page now cites and describes the October 2025 list. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Rowntree's

    The Arabic page translated Nestlé's 'Rowntree's Lollies' (lolly-shaped sweets sold in bags) as ice lollies, so it warned about the wrong product. It now names the Lollies sweets. Both pages also add four newer bags whose ingredients list gelatine of unstated source: Berry Hearts, Fizzy Cactuz, Bottle Pops and Fizzy Snakes. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Cheese

    The page said an Alba shredded mozzarella carries a Halal label. That came from an Open Food Facts tag; the pack photos show no Halal mark, so the claim is removed. Its non-animal rennet is unchanged. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Quorn

    The page said Open Food Facts records a Halal label on Quorn Pieces, 8 Sausages and Vegan Pieces. The pack photos confirm a Halal certified mark on Pieces and Sausages only; Vegan Pieces shows none. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Yeast Extract

    The page said Marmite's UK jars carry the Halal Food Authority mark, citing a pack record whose photos show no such mark, and called avoidance of brewer's yeast a 'minority' view without a source. It now cites Marmite's own statement that its range is HFA-certified, MUI's 2011 fatwa permitting washed brewer's-yeast extract, and Askimam and Darul Ifta Birmingham, who advise avoiding brewer's yeast. The HFA homepage, JAKIM portal and FDA links are removed. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Tempeh

    The page cited the FDA food homepage and the JAKIM portal for its general ruling, and said Halal-certified tempeh exists in Muslim markets without a source. It now cites Qur'an 2:168 and IslamQA 231261 on the default permissibility of food. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Seitan

    The page cited the FDA food homepage and the JAKIM portal for its general ruling. It now cites Qur'an 2:168 and IslamQA 231261 on the default permissibility of food. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Brownies

    The page cited the FDA food homepage and the JAKIM portal for its general ruling. It now cites Qur'an 2:168 and IslamQA 231261 on the default permissibility of food. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Dave's Hot Chicken

    The page's US paragraph cited the Dave's homepage, the USDA inspection service and the JAKIM portal, none of which addresses Halal at Dave's. It now cites Qur'an 5:3 on slaughter and the Halal Monitoring Committee's position on stunning (relevant to Dave's UK pre-stunned chicken). Verdict unchanged.

  • · Verdict changed

    Kettle Chips: Market-dependent → Halal if verified

    The page cited only the Kettle Brand homepage, the FDA and the JAKIM portal, and had no market with a different answer. Pack records show the answer changes with the flavour, not the country: plain salted bags from four brands are potato, oil and salt (Halal); Mature Cheddar lists cheese with no rennet stated (Halal if verified); Sea Salt & Balsamic Vinegar uses balsamic, a scholarly difference. The page is now Halal if verified.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Takis

    The page cited only the FDA, the Grupo Bimbo homepage and the JAKIM portal, and said Blue Heat contains dairy. Current US Blue Heat lists no dairy. The page now rests on pack records: US and UK Fuego and US Blue Heat have no dairy, meat or carmine (Halal by ingredients); Intense Nacho and Volcano list cheese (Halal if verified); US Takis Crisps Fuego and a Fuego sold in Brazil list carmine (scholarly difference). Overall verdict unchanged (Market-dependent).

  • · Evidence corrected

    Cheetos

    The page cited only the PepsiCo homepage, the JAKIM portal and the FDA. It now rests on pack records: Indonesian Cheetos, cheese flavours included, carry the Halal Indonesia logo (Halal); UK Twisted Sweet & Spicy has no dairy while Crunchy Cheese lists cheese powder (Halal if verified); US Crunchy and Flamin' Hot list cheddar with unnamed enzymes (Halal if verified). An unsourced line about carmine in some markets is removed. Overall verdict unchanged (Market-dependent).

  • · Evidence corrected

    Doritos

    The page cited only the Doritos homepage and the JAKIM portal, and said Malaysian and Gulf bags are commonly Halal without a source. It now rests on pack records: Indonesian bags made by PepsiCo Indonesia carry the Halal Indonesia logo (Halal); UK Original Salted and Chilli Heatwave have no dairy while cheese flavours list cheese powder (Halal if verified); US cheese flavours use animal enzymes per Frito-Lay's 2014 statement (Halal if verified). Overall verdict unchanged (Market-dependent).

  • · Evidence corrected

    Pringles

    The page said UK and US cans are generally not Halal-certified. The UK and European Original 185 g can in fact carries a Halal Food Authority mark and a vegan logo (pack photos, including July 2026), so that market is now Halal; the US Original, which lists mono- and diglycerides without a source, is Halal if verified. The 2010 Malaysian JAKIM statement is now dated as history. The Pringles homepage and JAKIM portal links are removed. Overall verdict unchanged (Market-dependent).

  • · Evidence corrected

    Nutella

    The certification section now cites NIHT's own directory, which lists Ferrero's Alba, Arlon and Villers-Écalles plants with Halal certificates valid to 28 February 2027, alongside Ferrero's statements. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Loukoumades

    The fryer and syrup checks now cite Qur'an 5:3 and 5:90, and Shaykh Faraz Rabbani's answer on food fried in oil shared with non-Halal meat (separate oil permitted, unknown oil better avoided, shared oil Haram). The Visit Cyprus homepage and unsourced 'usually' lines are removed. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Australian supermarket chicken

    A new stunning section cites Qur'an 5:3 and the Halal Monitoring Committee's position against stunning, alongside RSPCA's note that stunning is standard in many Australian Halal-certified abattoirs. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Maltodextrin

    The page now cites a Darul Ifta Birmingham (Hanafi) answer ruling maltodextrin Halal, and LPPOM MUI's note that certifiers check the enzyme used to break down the starch (animal enzymes must come from Halal-slaughtered animals). Before, it cited only US regulations. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Food Colouring

    The page now cites SANHA's E-number lists: curcumin, tartrazine, caramel colour, beta-carotene and calcium carbonate are listed Halaal, and carmine (E120) Haraam. Before, it cited only EU labelling law. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Verdict changed

    Lindt: Market-dependent → Halal if verified

    Lindt & Sprüngli's group FAQ says none of its production sites is Halal certified and none of its packaging carries a Halal label, so the page's 'Certified-market packs: Halal' tab had no basis and is removed. Every market now gives the same answer: Halal if verified, with the plain Excellence dark bars made without animal products or alcohol and liqueur products Haram. Qur'an 5:90 is cited for the alcohol products; the JAKIM portal and FDA links are removed.

  • · Evidence corrected

    E476 (PGPR)

    The page now cites SANHA's E-number entry, which lists E476 as mushbooh (doubtful) because the glycerol source must be checked, and Qur'an 5:3 for why animal glycerol matters. The FAQ no longer says PGPR is 'usually' Halal. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Root Beer

    The page now cites Qur'an 5:90 for why hard root beer is Haram, and IslamQA's ruling on fizzy drinks for the soft drink, which it does not name. The A&W homepage, the FDA labelling hub and an unsourced paragraph about Halal marks in Malaysia are removed; the brand answers rely on the pack records already on the page. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Popeyes

    The UK answer now cites the opening reports that say all of Popeyes' UK chicken is Halal (Time Out 2021, Moodie Davitt Report 2025) instead of the popeyes.co.uk homepage, and no longer claims certified suppliers. Unsourced lines about Canadian locations being 'Ontario-heavy' and about Popeyes being certified in every Muslim-majority market are removed. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Krispy Kreme

    The Malaysia answer said Krispy Kreme outlets there are commonly JAKIM-certified, with only the JAKIM portal homepage behind it. No published statement from the Malaysian operator was found, so the Malaysia tab now says Halal if verified: check the outlet's own JAKIM certificate.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Nando's

    The Malaysia answer said Nando's outlets there are commonly JAKIM-certified, with only the JAKIM portal homepage behind it. No published statement from the Malaysian operator was found, so the Malaysia tab now says Halal if verified: check the outlet's own JAKIM certificate.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Subway

    The Malaysia answer said Subway outlets there are commonly JAKIM-certified, with only the JAKIM portal homepage behind it. No published statement from the Malaysian operator was found, so the Malaysia tab now says Halal if verified: check the outlet's own JAKIM certificate. The restaurant finder's Subway Malaysia guide was corrected the same way.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Nutella

    The certified-market, US and UK tabs now point at the Ferrero pages they summarise (Malaysia, Indonesia, Australian Food Service; Nutella's US FAQ and Ferrero's worldwide-recipe page) instead of the JAKIM portal and nutella.com homepages. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Ferrero Rocher

    The certified-market tab now cites Ferrero's own Malaysia and Indonesia pages (NIHT certification acknowledged by JAKIM; BPJPH logo on every Ferrero product imported into Indonesia) instead of the JAKIM portal homepage. The US tab cites a US pack record; the UK tab, which cited only the brand homepage, is removed. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    KitKat

    The Malaysia answer now cites Nestlé Malaysia's own statement that all Nestlé products made, imported and sold in Malaysia are certified Halal by JAKIM or JAKIM-recognised bodies, replacing a generic 'certified markets' tab. The UK tab now cites a UK pack record instead of the Nestlé and JAKIM homepages. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Starburst

    The page said many current Starburst packs are gelatin-free and that Malaysian packs may carry Halal marks. Starburst's US site lists gelatin, with no source named, in Original Fruit Chews and Gummies, while UK packs list none; the page now says so, built on those product pages and UK pack records. The unsourced Malaysia claim and 'certified markets' tab are removed. Verdict unchanged (Market-dependent).

  • · Verdict changed

    Mars: Market-dependent → Halal if verified

    The page said Mars bars are certified in Malaysia and the Gulf, citing only the JAKIM portal homepage; no record supports it, so that claim and the 'certified markets' tab are removed. UK and German bars list no gelatin or E471 and carry no Halal mark, so the bar is Halal if verified. Added Qatar's and Kuwait's 2019 statements that Mars-brand high-protein bars contain non-Halal protein.

  • · Evidence corrected

    M&M's

    Removed the claim that M&M's made for Malaysia are JAKIM-certified Halal, and the 'certified markets' tab built on it: no record was found to support it. The US tab now cites US pack records (soy lecithin, synthetic colours, carnauba wax; no gelatin, carmine or E471), replacing a line that called the emulsifier and glaze undisclosed. Verdict unchanged (Market-dependent: the UK and EU answers are sourced).

  • · Evidence corrected

    Twix

    The certified-market tab, which cited only the JAKIM portal and Mars homepages, is now a Middle East and North Africa tab built on Mars's own statement that all Twix sold there is halal suitable. The US and UK tabs now cite the US product page and a UK pack record instead of homepages and FDA. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Oreos

    The certified-market tab now cites JAKIM's clarification that Oreo made by Mondelez Indonesia is certified Halal by BPJPH, which JAKIM recognises, instead of the JAKIM portal homepage.

  • · Evidence corrected

    KFC

    The Malaysia answer now cites JAKIM's own clarification that all KFC premises in Malaysia hold valid Malaysian Halal certificates. The unsourced claim about Indonesia and the generic 'certified markets' tab are removed.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Popeyes

    The unsourced 'Muslim-majority markets' tab (Halal) is replaced by a Turkey tab built on Popeyes Turkey's published supplier Halal certificates. Its chicken certificate (TSE, hand slaughter) ran until 30 September 2026, so the tab says Halal if verified until a renewal is shown.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Wingstop

    Removed a 'certified locations / markets' tab that had no source. The US and UK tabs, which cite Wingstop's own pages, are unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Cadbury

    The 'other certified markets' tab, which cited only the JAKIM portal homepage, is replaced by an Australia and New Zealand tab built on Cadbury Australia's own HCAA-certified list. The US tab now cites US (Hershey-made) Cadbury pack records instead of FDA and Mondelēz homepages. Verdict unchanged (Market-dependent, with the sourced Malaysia tab).

  • · Verdict changed

    Toblerone: Market-dependent → Halal if verified

    The 2018 Bern factory certification now cites Mondelēz's own statement (via CNN and Halal Focus), including that the certification is not shown on the pack. The 'certified markets' tab cited only the JAKIM portal homepage and was removed; with no mark on the pack and no current certificate, the page is Halal if verified. A repeated block of body text was also removed.

  • · Verdict changed

    Milky Way: Market-dependent → Halal if verified

    The 'certified markets' tab rested on the JAKIM portal homepage alone, with no record of a certified Milky Way. US, UK and German bars all list no gelatin and carry no Halal mark, so the answer follows the product. Now built on US and UK pack records (plus Midnight and the UK hot chocolate, which lists E471) and IslamQA on default permissibility.

  • · Verdict changed

    Hershey's: Market-dependent → Halal if verified

    No source showed a market where Hershey's is certified Halal; the 'certified markets' tab rested on the JAKIM portal homepage alone. The answer follows the product instead: plain bars and Kisses list no gelatin, Marshmallow Eggs list gelatin of unnamed source, and the classic syrup lists E471. Built on named US pack records, Hershey's kosher and PGPR pages, IslamQA and Qur'an 5:3.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Snickers

    Removed the unsourced claim that JAKIM certifies Snickers in Malaysia; the certified-market tab is now Middle East and North Africa, based on Mars's own statement. Added a UK pack record, a UK ice cream record (which lists E471) and IslamQA on the default permissibility of food; dropped homepage and FDA sources. Verdict unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Jell-O

    Now built on named US and Canadian Jell-O pack records (gelatin with no animal named, no Halal mark) and two pudding mixes with no gelatin, plus Qur'an 5:3 and IMAM-US on gelatin. The unsourced claim that North American Jell-O gelatin is pork has been removed; the page now says the source is not named.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Candy corn

    Now built on three US pack records (one with gelatin of unnamed source, two without gelatin), SANHA's shellac listing and MUI Fatwa 27/2013; it now says shellac is Halal on this site, as the shellac page does, rather than leaving it to personal standard.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Dark chocolate

    Now cites Qur'an 5:90 for liqueur centres, a UK cherry liqueur chocolate that is 11% cherry brandy spirit, and Lindt Excellence 85%, which lists no emulsifier.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Agar-agar (E406)

    Now cites Qur'an 5:96 and two single-ingredient agar pack records, and drops unsourced claims that certifiers list E406 without qualification and that JAKIM prefers agar.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Goat

    Now cites Qur'an 6:142–143, which names goats among lawful livestock, and HMC's stunning standard, and no longer says in the text that the verdict is Halal when it is Halal if verified.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Burgers

    Now cites McDonald's UK and Malaysia, Burger King UK and Five Guys UK for which chains serve Halal meat, and corrects two errors: beef tallow is Halal if verified, not Haram, and vinegar in sauces is a scholarly difference.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Cookies

    Now built on named pack records (McVitie's Digestives, Wagon Wheels with beef gelatine, Maryland, Chips Ahoy!) instead of generic homepages.

  • · Verdict changed

    Chick-fil-A: Halal if verified → Haram

    Chick-fil-A's own FAQ says none of its menu items meet Halal standards. Other chains that say the same (Prezzo, Zizzi, Toby Carvery, Miller & Carter) are Haram here, so Chick-fil-A now is too. Its UK restaurants, now covered on the page, make no Halal claim.

  • · Verdict changed

    Dave's Hot Chicken: Halal if verified → Market-dependent

    The page covered only the US and Canada. Dave's UK FAQ says all the chicken in its restaurants is Halal, from certified suppliers and pre-stunned, while its kitchens don't follow Halal procedures. The page now has UK and US panels.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Mentos

    Gelatin claim corrected. The page said chewy Mentos in Western markets contain gelatin and that the classic roll always does. Pack records updated in 2026 for the UK, the US and Europe list no gelatin (gellan, cellulose and arabic gums instead). The page now says so, and names the emulsifiers (sucrose esters, and mono- and diglycerides in the US) as the open question; the status stays Halal if verified.

  • · Evidence corrected

    KFC

    Canada corrected. The page said KFC Canada had no Halal programme. KFC Canada said that from 15 May 2024 all chicken at its Ontario restaurants, except Thunder Bay and Ottawa, is Halal-certified; the page now has a Canada panel (Halal if verified) citing that notice as reported by NOW Toronto and Daily Hive, and still notes CBC Marketplace's findings.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Shellfish

    Verdict unchanged (Scholarly difference). The table said crustaceans including crab are permitted in many Shafi'i readings; the stronger Shafi'i view forbids crab. It now says so, and that Hanafi scholars differ on shrimp, with a source.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Carmine (E120)

    Verdict unchanged (Scholarly difference). The page said Maliki scholars allow carmine because the school permits insects. The Maliki school permits insects only when they are killed in order to be eaten, and a Maliki answer (SeekersGuidance, Shaykh Rami Nsour) finds that carmine, as it is made, does not meet that condition. The permissive side is Jordan's Iftaa' Department and Indonesia's MUI, with conditions.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Crab

    Verdict unchanged (Scholarly difference). The page said the Shafi'i school permits crab. The IslamWeb fatwa it cites says the Shafi'i school has two views and the stronger one forbids crab (al-Nawawi: "the frog and the crab are forbidden"); the Maliki and Hanbali schools permit it. The page now says so.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Oreos

    Verdict unchanged. The page said Oreo emulsifiers are often mono- and diglycerides; classic EU packs list soya and sunflower lecithin. A table still used the older Market-dependent label for uncertified Oreos; it now says Halal if verified, matching the country panels.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Toblerone

    Verdict unchanged. The page said uncertified bars raised an E471 emulsifier question. Current UK, US and EU packs list soya lecithin as the emulsifier, with no E471 and no gelatin, so the page now names the flavouring as the one unaudited point and cites each pack.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Twix

    Verdict unchanged. The US and UK panels already showed Halal if verified, but their text still called the US answer Market-dependent, an older label. The text now matches the badge, and three near-identical FAQs are merged into one.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Snickers

    Verdict unchanged. An FAQ said the US verdict was Market-dependent while the US panel showed Halal if verified; it now says Halal if verified. A duplicate FAQ is removed.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Milky Way

    Verdict unchanged. The US and UK panel text named Market-dependent while their badges showed Halal if verified; the text now matches. A duplicate FAQ is removed.

  • · Evidence corrected

    CAVA (restaurant)

    Verdict unchanged (Halal if verified). We had said CAVA published no Halal statement; its own X account said in 2017 that the meat in its braised lamb is certified Halal, and in 2020 that its spicy lamb meatballs are not. The page now cites both.

  • · Evidence corrected

    M&M's

    The UK verdict is now Haram, from Halal if verified. The official M&M's UK account said in 2019 that no variety is suitable for a Halal diet, and UK peanut and crispy packs list carmine (E120). Other markets are unchanged.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Wingstop

    Verdict unchanged (Market-dependent). The UK section now cites Wingstop UK's own FAQ, which says its Halal chickens are stunned before slaughter, instead of the US homepage.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Vinegar

    New section on vinegar inside other foods: accepted in bought products, as JAKIM-certified mayonnaise shows, except a label that says wine vinegar. Malaysia's 2006 fatwa is now scoped to wine vinegar.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Ketchup

    Verdict unchanged (Halal). The page had cited IslamQA 2283 as permitting deliberately made vinegar, which it does not; it now cites the Shafi'i, IslamQA 191176 and JAKIM evidence for vinegar in bought food.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Mayonnaise

    Verdict unchanged (Halal). The vinegar is now sourced to the Shafi'i and IslamQA rulings on commercial vinegar and to JAKIM's certification of Kewpie mayonnaise.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Mustard

    Verdict unchanged (Halal) for yellow mustard. Dijon made with wine vinegar is now marked a scholarly difference instead of Halal.

  • · Verdict changed

    Taurine: Halal → Halal if verified

    Only Red Bull publishes that its taurine is synthetic. For other brands the source needs the maker's statement or a Halal certificate.

  • · Verdict changed

    Monster Energy: Halal → Halal if verified

    The Darul Iftaa Birmingham fatwa covers the original drink's listed ingredients only. Other lines differ, and the Beast Unleashed line is alcoholic.

  • · Verdict changed

    Eel: Halal if verified → Scholarly difference

    The eel itself changes status by school: Hanafi rulings permit it as a fish; Ja'fari rulings require scales. The unagi glaze is a separate check.

  • · Verdict changed

    Catfish: Halal → Scholarly difference

    Sunni rulings treat catfish as a fish, but Ja'fari rulings, including Sayyid al-Sistani's, forbid fish without scales.

  • · Verdict changed

    Caviar: Halal → Scholarly difference

    Sturgeon is disputed: Sunni rulings permit it; some Ja'fari references exclude it, while Ayatollah Khomeini ruled sturgeon with scales near the tail halal in 1983. Salmon and trout roe stay Halal.

  • · Verdict changed

    Horse Meat: Halal → Halal if verified

    Horse is a permitted species for most scholars, but like beef and lamb the meat needs Islamic slaughter.

  • · Verdict changed

    Vinegar: Halal → Scholarly difference

    Commercial vinegar is made on purpose from an alcoholic liquid, and fatwa bodies split: the Hanafi school and Indonesia's MUI permit it; the classical Shafi'i rule and Malaysia's National Fatwa Committee do not.

  • · Verdict changed

    Malt Vinegar: Halal if verified → Scholarly difference

    Malt vinegar is judged like every other deliberately made vinegar; see Vinegar.

  • · Verdict changed

    Balsamic Vinegar: Halal → Scholarly difference

    Commercial balsamic is deliberately made vinegar, which fatwa bodies split on; see Vinegar.

  • · Verdict changed

    Apple Cider Vinegar: Halal → Scholarly difference

    Cider vinegar starts as cider and is judged like every other deliberately made vinegar; see Vinegar.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Chick-fil-A

    Now cites Chick-fil-A's own FAQ: none of its menu items meet Halal standards. Unsourced claims about shared oil and franchises were removed.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Marmite

    Scoped to the UK range, which Marmite says the Halal Food Authority certifies; the dispute over brewer's yeast extract is now named.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Mineral colours (calcium carbonate, iron oxides, aluminium, silver, gold)

    The rulings on eating gold and silver leaf are now credited to IslamWeb and Darul Iftaa Mahmudiyyah, with their conditions.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Tea

    Scoped to plain tea and sourced to named Shafi'i and Hanafi rulings; unsourced consensus claims were removed.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Red Bull

    Unsourced certifier claims replaced by two named fatwas and Red Bull's own taurine statement.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Lamb

    HMC's no-stunning rule is credited to HMC only; unsourced market claims were removed.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Haggis

    Rewritten around a maker's actual ingredient lists; 'only if labelled Halal' was replaced, since home-made haggis with Halal meat is Halal.

  • · Evidence corrected

    CAVA (restaurant)

    Now cites CAVA's 2025 annual report, and no longer infers a negative from a blocked website.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Red Wine Vinegar

    Verdict unchanged (Scholarly difference) but now sourced to the national fatwa bodies on both sides; see Vinegar.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Spirit Vinegar

    Verdict unchanged (Scholarly difference) but now sourced to the national fatwa bodies on both sides; see Vinegar.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Beef Gelatin

    Now sets out the named dispute over gelatin from cattle not slaughtered Islamically.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Chorizo

    Now names a certified Halal beef chorizo alongside the traditional pork product.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Pork Gelatin

    No longer says all four schools agree with no meaningful disagreement, or that every major certifier rejects istihalah, which no source showed. The Haram verdict now rests on IslamQA, HMC's gelatine statement and Shafi'i and Hanafi rulings, and the page sets out where the istihalah debate lies. An unsourced 60–80% market-share figure was removed.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Gelatin

    The claim that food certifiers do not accept istihalah for pork gelatin now cites HMC's gelatine statement and two fatwas, replacing the JAKIM, IFANCA, SANHA and FDA homepages.

  • · Verdict changed

    Greggs: Market-dependent → Haram

    Moved from Market-dependent to Haram. Greggs' FAQs (checked again on 8 October 2026) say it has no Halal menu or range and can't label anything Halal because its shops and bakeries have no separation, and no market with a different answer has a source. This follows the rule already applied to Chick-fil-A, Prezzo and Zizzi.

  • · Verdict changed

    Lay's: Market-dependent → Halal if verified

    Moved from Market-dependent to Halal if verified. The answer turns on the flavour, not the country: Classic is potatoes, oil and salt, while flavoured bags can carry cheese, meat or enzyme seasonings, and no market with a different Halal answer has a source.

  • · Verdict changed

    Marmite: Halal → Scholarly difference

    Moved from Halal to Scholarly difference. Marmite says its UK range is HFA-certified, but it is made from brewer's yeast, on which the cited scholars differ: IslamWeb permits it, Darul Uloom Trinidad does not. The site uses Scholarly difference wherever the answer turns on which view you follow, as with spirit and balsamic vinegar.

  • · Verdict changed

    Yeast Extract: Halal → Scholarly difference

    Moved from Halal to Scholarly difference. Extract from baker's yeast is Halal, but much yeast extract comes from brewer's yeast, which MUI permits once washed and Askimam and Darul Ifta Birmingham advise avoiding.

  • · Verdict changed

    Vegemite: Halal → Scholarly difference

    Moved from Halal to Scholarly difference, matching Marmite. Vegemite's FAQ says it is certified Halal by the HCA (the page had said certification varied by market), but it is made from brewers' yeast, which IslamWeb permits and Askimam and Darul Ifta Birmingham advise avoiding.

  • · Verdict changed

    Fanta: Market-dependent → Halal if verified

    Moved from Market-dependent to Halal if verified. The only sourced market, the US, is Halal if verified, and the open question is the flavour (Orange adds E445, whose glycerol source is unstated), not the country.

  • · Verdict changed

    Skittles: Market-dependent → Halal if verified

    Moved from Market-dependent to Halal if verified. US, UK and EU packs read the same way (core range with no gelatin or carmine, not certified); what differs is the product, such as Skittles Gummies and Squishy Cloudz, which list gelatin of unnamed source.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Packaging gases (E290, E938–E949)

    The page said certifier lists put all these gases with the additives that need no check, and that carbon dioxide is not a sign of fermentation. SANHA lists carbon dioxide (E290) as Mushbooh because one of its sources is fermentation in alcohol production, and US rules name fermentation among its sources; the page now says so. The table's uses now come from SANHA's and the US rules' own lists.

  • · Verdict changed

    Ammonium phosphatides (E442): Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. SANHA's own E442 entry lists it as Halaal, from a synthetic chemical source. The page had cited SANHA for putting E442 among the codes to check, which its entry does not do.

  • · Verdict changed

    Ascorbyl palmitate (E304): Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. SANHA's E304 entry lists it as Halaal, from a synthetic chemical source, and E304 is not on SANHA's list of doubtful E-numbers, which the page had cited for it.

  • · Verdict changed

    Lecithin (E322): Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. SANHA lists E322 as Halaal, from soybean (mainly), eggs and leguminous seeds, with no condition on a bare 'lecithin' label.

  • · Verdict changed

    Toffifee: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Storck's Toffifee FAQ says 'Toffifee is 100% halal', with no gelatine or alcohol; other pages rated on a maker's statement, such as Nutella, are Halal.

  • · Verdict changed

    McCoy's Thai Sweet Chicken: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal by ingredients. No meat is listed, and KP Snacks lists the flavour as suitable for vegetarians and alcohol free.

  • · Verdict changed

    Smints: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. No Smint pack lists gelatin, meat or alcohol, and Smint UK marks the XXL Peppermint tin suitable for vegans, which settles its one animal-possible ingredient (E470b).

  • · Evidence corrected

    M&M's

    UK tab moved from Haram to Scholarly difference and US tab from Halal if verified to Halal. The current M&M's UK FAQ says M&M's contain no pork-based ingredients and that red ones use a non-vegetarian colouring (UK packs list carmine, on which scholars differ); US packs list synthetic colours and no gelatin or carmine.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Tartaric acid (E334)

    The page said certifiers treat food-grade tartrates as Halal and cited SANHA, but SANHA lists E334 as Mushbooh. The Halal rating now rests on a Muftionline fatwa (cream of tartar from wine is halaal by complete transformation), and SANHA's view is shown.

  • · Verdict changed

    Tic Tacs: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Ferrero says UK Fresh Mint is suitable for vegans and TIC TAC TWO is Halal-certified, and the UK Halal Food Guide rules the mint flavours Halal; flavours coloured with carmine (E120) are shown as a scholarly difference.

  • · Verdict changed

    Beef gelatin: Halal if verified → Scholarly difference

    Moved to Scholarly difference. The page already named the split on uncertified beef gelatin: IslamWeb permits fully transformed gelatin, while Hanafi rulings (Fatwaa.com, Darul Ifta Birmingham) and HMC do not. Halal-certified beef gelatin is Halal on every view.

  • · Verdict changed

    Hershey's: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal by ingredients. The plain milk bar, Special Dark and plain Kisses list no gelatin or animal fat, and Hershey's says its PGPR is made from castor, soybean and sunflower oil; the marshmallow products (gelatin of unnamed source) are named as the ones to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Monster Energy: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Darul Iftaa Birmingham ruled the original drink permissible on its listed ingredients and Monster says its taurine is synthetic; the alcoholic Beast Unleashed line is named as Haram and other lines keep their own conditions.

  • · Verdict changed

    Lay's: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Plain Lay's is potatoes, oil and salt (US Classic page; the German Salted bag is labelled vegan), so the base is Halal and the risks come only from flavour seasonings, which the page now names: pork or bacon makes a bag Haram, and cheese or whey seasonings carry the rennet question.

  • · Verdict changed

    Kimchi: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Kimchi is fermented vegetables, fish sauce is Halal, and the cited IslamWeb fatwa permits natural non-intoxicating fermentation alcohol; the only open point, salted shrimp paste under the Hanafi view of shellfish, stays in the conditions.

  • · Verdict changed

    Worcestershire Sauce: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. The anchovies are fish, the cited Hanafi, Shafi'i and IslamQA answers accept the vinegar in a bought sauce, the US Lea & Perrins list has no pork, meat or added alcohol, and Fatwa.org.au answers that Worcestershire sauce is Halal when it contains no haram ingredients. Wine vinegar stays a scholarly difference, and a bottle listing wine or added alcohol is one to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Gelato: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Gelato is milk, sugar and a little cream, or fruit, sugar and water for sorbetto, so the risk comes only from particular flavours: rum, Marsala, liqueur and wine flavours are Haram, carmine is a scholarly difference, and cheese swirls follow the rennet question. Two unsourced claims about plant-gum bases were removed.

  • · Verdict changed

    Lindt: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal, with the Canada, US and UK/EU market tabs. Lindt's Canada and US pages say all its chocolates, Lindor and Excellence included, are suitable for vegetarians, with animal products limited to milk, milk fat, cream, shellac and sometimes eggs; the few products with alcohol or liqueur list it on the label and stay Haram. Lindt holds no Halal certificate, which the page still says.

  • · Verdict changed

    Fanta: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal, with the US market tab, and a UK tab added. Fanta's published US and UK ingredient lists have no animal ingredients, no carmine and no alcohol. US Orange and UK Lemon and Fruit Twist add E445, whose glycerol source is unpublished and which SANHA lists as Mashbooh; those flavours are named in the conditions for readers who avoid E445.

  • · Verdict changed

    Gatorade: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. US Thirst Quencher and Zero list water, sugars or sweeteners, salts, acids, flavouring and colours, with no animal ingredient or alcohol. Glycerol ester of rosin (E445), whose glycerol source is unstated and which SANHA lists as Mashbooh, is named in the conditions for readers who avoid it.

  • · Verdict changed

    Lucozade: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Lucozade Energy Original and Sport Orange list nothing animal-derived and no alcohol. Sport Raspberry and Ice Kick add E445, whose glycerol source is unstated and which SANHA lists as Mashbooh; they are named in the conditions for readers who avoid it.

  • · Verdict changed

    Celsius: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Celsius lists only plant, mineral and synthetic ingredients and no alcohol, and the Sparkling Orange can is certified vegan (vegan.org), which rules out animal-derived taurine. It carries no Halal mark, which the page still says.

  • · Verdict changed

    Mars: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal, with the UK and EU market tabs. UK and German Mars bars list no gelatin, no E471, no alcohol and nothing from pork; whey permeate (the rennet question) is named in the conditions. Mars high-protein bars stay a separate product to skip, on Qatar's 2019 health-ministry statement.

  • · Verdict changed

    Galaxy: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Galaxy's own ingredient lists for Smooth Milk, Smooth Caramel and Minstrels show no gelatine, alcohol or animal fat; whey permeate (the rennet question) is named in the conditions, and an unsourced 'most Muslims eat it' was replaced. Galaxy is not Halal-certified, which the page still says.

  • · Verdict changed

    Milky Way: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal, with the US, UK and EU market tabs. The classic US, UK and German bars list no gelatin and no alcohol (egg-white nougat); whey permeate on the UK and German bars is named as the rennet question, the UK hot chocolate's E471 is named, and Milky Way high-protein bars stay a product to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Maltesers: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Maltesers' own FAQ says the range is vegetarian, which rules out gelatine and animal rennet in the whey; the small amount of natural vanilla extract is permitted in finished food by IslamQA 177030 and Darul Iftaa Chicago, with the stricter view named in the conditions.

  • · Verdict changed

    Dairy Milk: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Cadbury Dairy Milk is certified Halal in Australia and New Zealand (HCAA) and Malaysia (JAKIM), and Cadbury UK lists the Dairy Milk range among its vegetarian chocolate, which settles the source of the UK bar's E476 and flavourings. Filled and liqueur-named variants are named as ones to read separately.

  • · Verdict changed

    Celebrations: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. The UK 550 g tub states 'Suitable for Vegetarians', which rules out gelatine and animal rennet and makes its E471 and glycerol non-slaughter fats; vanilla extract on some packs is permitted in finished food by IslamQA 177030 and Darul Iftaa Chicago. An unsourced 'most Muslims eat them' was replaced.

  • · Verdict changed

    Toblerone: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal, with the market tabs. Mondelēz said in 2018 that its Bern factory, which makes Toblerone, is Halal-certified with no recipe change, and current UK, US and German packs list no gelatin, no E471 and no alcohol. The certification is not printed on the pack, which the page still says.

  • · Verdict changed

    Rowntree's: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the core range. Nestlé says Jelly Tots, Fruit Pastilles, Fruit Gums and Pick & Mix have no gelatine and that all their ingredients are suitable for vegans. The page now calls Randoms, Squidgers and Rowntree's Lollies Haram (pork gelatine, per Nestlé) and says to skip the newer bags that list gelatine.

  • · Verdict changed

    Smarties: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Nestlé UK says Smarties and Smarties Buttons are suitable for vegetarians, which also rules out animal rennet in the whey, and the UK list has no gelatine or carmine. Nestlé also says no Smarties product is Halal-certified, which the page still says.

  • · Verdict changed

    Skittles: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal, with the US, UK and EU tabs. The official US Original and Sour pages and the UK Fruits page list no gelatin, carmine or other animal ingredient, Mars UK says the core range is vegan except Squishy Cloudz, and a German pack is marked vegan. Skittles Gummies and Squishy Cloudz list gelatin of unnamed source, and the page says to skip them.

  • · Verdict changed

    Airheads: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the classic bars and mini bars, whose lists have no animal ingredient. The page names Xtremes (carmine) as a scholarly difference and now says to skip Bites, whose glycerol and sucrose esters have no stated source.

  • · Verdict changed

    Altoids: Halal if verified → Haram

    Moved to Haram for the classic mints. Their labels list gelatin without naming the animal, and Wrigley's customer service said in 2017, in an email quoted by Confectionery News, that Altoids mints sold in the US contain gelatin from a mix of beef and pork. Altoids Arctic sugar-free mints have no gelatin; the page still notes their magnesium stearate has no stated source.

  • · Verdict changed

    Chupa Chups: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Fruit, sour and mini lollipops list no animal ingredient and no gelatine. The cream flavours add whey powder, which the page now calls Halal on the Hanafi view of rennet (GMWA Food Guide), with a skip option for those who require Halal rennet.

  • · Verdict changed

    Jolly Rancher: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the hard candy and recent Gummies Sours, whose lists have no gelatin or other animal ingredient. Fruit Chews and the original Gummies list gelatin without naming the animal, and the page now says to skip them.

  • · Verdict changed

    Sour Punch: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the gummies, which are set with corn starch and list nothing from an animal. Sour Punch Bites list glyceryl monostearate and glycerin of unstated source, and the page now says to skip them.

  • · Verdict changed

    Swedish Fish: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. US packs and Mondelēz's product pages list no gelatin and nothing from an animal: the chew comes from corn starch. The page still says they carry no Halal mark, and an unsourced 'most Muslims eat them' line was replaced.

  • · Verdict changed

    Swizzels: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the sweets on Swizzels' own vegan list (Love Hearts, Parma Violets, Drumstick lollies, Fizzers, Refreshers and others). The page now calls Squashies, Drumstick Squashies included, Haram: the Squashies account says they use pork gelatine.

  • · Verdict changed

    Tootsie Roll: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal on the Hanafi view of rennet (GMWA Food Guide). Tootsie Rolls list no gelatin or meat product; the only question is the whey, and the page says to skip them if you require Halal rennet.

  • · Verdict changed

    Twizzlers: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for Strawberry Twists, whose list has nothing from an animal. The page now says to skip Black Licorice and filled twists (glycerin of unstated source) and Twizzlers Gummies (gelatin), and unsourced 'most Muslims' lines were replaced.

  • · Verdict changed

    Fruittella: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Fruittella's UK FAQ says the range no longer contains gelatine and the classic chewy range is suitable for vegetarians and vegans, which makes its glycerol and E471 plant-based. The page says to skip any older bag that still lists gelatine.

  • · Verdict changed

    Chewits: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Cloetta's UK FAQ says Chewits Chews and Xtreme are vegetarian (no gelatine) and Bites, Laces, Twists and Wands are vegan, which settles the sucrose-ester emulsifier. The page now says to avoid Chewits Jewels, which Cloetta says contain gelatine, and shows that an older bites pack listing carmine disagrees with Cloetta's vegan statement.

  • · Verdict changed

    Mike and Ike: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. The boxes list no gelatin or land-animal ingredient: Just Born says the chew is corn starch, and the shellac glaze is ruled Halal by MUI fatwa 27/2013. Just Born says they are kosher pareve but not Halal-certified, which the page still says.

  • · Verdict changed

    Mamba: Halal if verified → Scholarly difference

    Moved to Scholarly difference. Storck's consumer FAQ says Mamba's gelatin is from beef, with no Halal slaughter stated and no Halal mark. Darul Ifta Birmingham holds such gelatine not Halal; IslamWeb permits it as fully transformed.

  • · Verdict changed

    Cadbury Mini Eggs: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. UK Mini Eggs list no gelatine, carmine or alcohol, and Cadbury UK's vegetarian chocolate listing includes Mini Eggs, which rules out animal rennet in the whey permeate. The page no longer relies on an Open Food Facts vegetarian tag that the photographed panel does not show.

  • · Verdict changed

    Extra chewing gum: Halal if verified → Market-dependent

    Moved to Market-dependent, with UK and US tabs. UK Extra is listed as suitable for vegetarians, which rules out animal glycerol, so it is Halal there. US Extra lists glycerol with no vegetarian claim; US Extra Refreshers list none and are Halal.

  • · Verdict changed

    Trident gum: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for flavours without glycerin, such as US spearmint, which list nothing from an animal. The page now says to skip flavours that list glycerin or E422 of unstated source.

  • · Verdict changed

    Wagon Wheels: Halal if verified → Scholarly difference

    Moved to Scholarly difference. Original and Jammie use beef gelatine with no Halal slaughter stated: Darul Ifta Birmingham would not count it as Halal, IslamWeb permits it as transformed. Jammie Teacakes use pork gelatine and are now named Haram. Unsourced 'most scholars' and 'minority' lines were replaced with the named views.

  • · Verdict changed

    Mr Kipling: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the cakes on Mr Kipling's own vegetarian list, which have no animal ingredients. The classic Angel Slices contain carmine and stay a named scholarly difference on the page.

  • · Verdict changed

    Pop-Tarts: Halal if verified → Scholarly difference

    Moved to Scholarly difference. The brand says all frosted flavours use beef gelatin, with no Halal slaughter stated: Darul Ifta Birmingham would not count it as Halal, IslamWeb permits it as transformed. Unfrosted Pop-Tarts have no gelatin. Unsourced 'most Muslims' and 'minority' lines were replaced with the named views.

  • · Verdict changed

    Chips Ahoy!: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. US Original and Chewy cookies list no gelatin, lard, whey or alcohol, only plant oils, flour, sugar, chocolate and milk. They carry a kosher mark, not a Halal one, which the page still says.

  • · Verdict changed

    Cheez-It: Halal if verified → Scholarly difference

    Moved to Scholarly difference. The cheese is made with enzymes of unnamed source: SeekersGuidance (Hanafi) permits non-pork rennet, while IslamQA reports that most Maliki, Shafi'i and Hanbali scholars hold rennet from an animal not slaughtered Islamically to be impure.

  • · Verdict changed

    Goldfish crackers: Halal if verified → Scholarly difference

    Moved to Scholarly difference. Cheddar Goldfish use cheese enzymes of unnamed source: SeekersGuidance (Hanafi) permits non-pork rennet, IslamQA reports most Maliki, Shafi'i and Hanbali scholars do not. Goldfish Original has no cheese and is named as the buy.

  • · Verdict changed

    Funyuns: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for US Funyuns Onion, Flamin' Hot Onion and Baked Onion rings: Frito-Lay lists them as made without pork enzymes, and the bags list no cheese, gelatin or alcohol. Spicy Queso and other flavours off that list are named to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Kettle Chips: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Plain salted bags from Kettle Brand, Cape Cod, Boulder Canyon and UK Kettle list only potatoes, oil and salt, and flavours such as jalapeño add nothing animal-derived. Cheese flavours (rennet) and balsamic flavours (wine vinegar) are named as scholarly differences.

  • · Verdict changed

    Monster Munch: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal. Neither flavour lists meat; the Pickled Onion pack photo shows 'Suitable for Vegetarians', which settles its whey permeate, and the Roast Beef whey permeate is Halal on the Hanafi view of rennet (GMWA Food Guide).

  • · Verdict changed

    Pot Noodle: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the classic meat-free flavours, which the GMWA Food Guide's Unilever list puts on its permissible list. The beef pho pot and the Pot Pasta range, which contain meat, are named Haram on the page.

  • · Verdict changed

    Shin Ramyun: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the Korean-made Shin Ramyun sold in the UK, Germany and Norway, which carries a Halal logo and lists no meat. Packs without the logo are named as needing their own check.

  • · Verdict changed

    Maggi noodles: Halal if verified → Market-dependent

    Split by country. India: Halal for every 2-minute flavour except Chicken, which Nestlé India says are vegetarian and contain no pork. Australia: kept Halal if verified, because the 2 Minute Noodles list flavour enhancer 635 of unstated source and carry no Halal mark.

  • · Verdict changed

    Dolmio: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the Bolognese and Lasagne Creamy White Sauce, which list no meat, alcohol or cheese. The Creamy Tomato Pasta Bake (white wine) and Stir-in Carbonara (pork ham) are now named Haram, and the cheese sauces are shown as a scholarly difference over the rennet.

  • · Verdict changed

    Angel Delight: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal: the sachet has no gelatine and carries the ‘Suitable for Vegetarians’ mark (checked on a 2024 pack photo), which rules out animal fat in the E477 emulsifier and animal rennet behind the whey.

  • · Verdict changed

    Jell-O: Halal if verified → Haram

    Moved to Haram for the gelatin desserts and gelatin cups: they list gelatin with no Halal mark, and Kraft's consumer relations said in 2007 that most of the gelatin in Kraft Foods products is made from North American pork. Pudding mixes without gelatin are named separately.

  • · Verdict changed

    Hartley's jelly: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the ready-to-eat pots set with plant gums, which have no animal ingredients. A Hartley's jelly that lists pork gelatine, such as the orange flavour jelly, is now named Haram.

  • · Verdict changed

    Häagen-Dazs: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the plain flavours: they are cream, milk, sugar and egg yolk, and the brand says it uses no other animal-derived ingredients apart from marshmallow gelatine. Rum Raisin and spirit flavours are named Haram and marshmallow flavours as ones to avoid.

  • · Verdict changed

    Wall's ice cream: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal: the GMWA's 2026 Food Guide lists the UK Wall's range as permissible, accepting whey rennet on the Hanafi view. Calippo, Twister, Cornetto Vegan and Cornetto Soft are named for those who require Halal rennet.

  • · Verdict changed

    Blue Bell: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for Homemade Vanilla and other flavours with no gelatin: Blue Bell's own product page lists only dairy, sugars, flavouring, plant gums, annatto and salt. Rocky Road and marshmallow flavours, which list gelatin of unnamed source, are named as ones to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Tillamook: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal: Tillamook says most of its cheese is Halal-certified and all but Maker's Reserve 10-Year uses Halal-certified fermentation rennet, and that its other dairy is vegetarian except Rocky Road ice cream. Maker's Reserve 10-Year is shown as a rennet scholarly difference and Rocky Road as one to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    NAYA: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the chicken shawarma, which NAYA labels Halal, and the vegetarian falafel and cauliflower. The beef shawarma, chicken kebab, kafta and lamb kebab carry no Halal label and are named as ones to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Myprotein: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the flavours on Myprotein's Halal certification list. Flavours not on the list are named as ones to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Optimum Nutrition: Halal if verified → Scholarly difference

    Moved to Scholarly difference: Gold Standard 100% Whey is not Halal-certified but lists no gelatin, and the Double Rich Chocolate is alcohol-free, so the answer turns on the whey's rennet, accepted on the Hanafi view and not on the majority view.

  • · Verdict changed

    Aptamil: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal: Aptamil says most of its UK milks are Halal-certified and lists them. The few it lists as not certified, such as the toddler ready-to-feed bottles and the Organic 800 g powders, are named with a certified alternative.

  • · Verdict changed

    Domino's: Halal if verified → Haram

    Moved to Haram (not Halal) for Domino's UK meat: Domino's says it does not promote any store or meat as Halal-approved. The page still shows that most of its chicken is Halal-certified at source in Thailand and stunned, and names meat-free pizzas.

  • · Verdict changed

    Papa John's: Halal if verified → Haram

    Moved to Haram (not Halal) for Papa John's UK meat: its 2023 welfare report says it does not promote any product as Halal, and its UK account says its products have never been Halal. Older posts naming Halal chicken are shown as superseded.

  • · Verdict changed

    Pizza Express: Halal if verified → Haram

    Moved to Haram (not Halal) for PizzaExpress meat dishes: it says it is not Halal-certified and cannot guarantee any menu item is Halal. The page still shows that some of its chicken is from Halal-slaughter suppliers.

  • · Verdict changed

    Pizza Pizza: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal when ordered with the Halal toppings Pizza Pizza names: Halal grilled chicken, Halal pepperoni and Halal beef crumble. Its pork toppings are named Haram and its regular chicken and beef as ones to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Franco Manca: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the chicken, which Franco Manca says is Halal, and the meat-free pizzas. Its fennel sausage and bresaola are named as not Halal meat, and its pork toppings as Haram.

  • · Verdict changed

    Bella Italia: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the poultry, which Bella Italia says comes from a Halal-certified supply chain. Its owner's policy requires stunning, which HFA accepts and HMC does not, so HMC followers are pointed to vegetarian dishes; other meats carry no Halal claim and are named as ones to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Frankie & Benny's: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the poultry, which Frankie & Benny's says comes from a Halal-certified supply chain. Its owner's policy requires stunning, which HFA accepts and HMC does not, so HMC followers are pointed to vegetarian dishes; other meats carry no Halal claim and are named as ones to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Las Iguanas: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the chicken, which Las Iguanas says comes from a Halal-certified supply chain. Its owner's policy requires stunning, which HFA accepts and HMC does not, so HMC followers are pointed to vegetarian dishes; other meats carry no Halal claim and are named as ones to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    itsu: Halal if verified → Haram

    Moved to Haram (not Halal) for itsu's meat dishes: itsu says its meat is not Halal-certified, and that its sushi rice and miso soup are not Halal either. Vinegar from wine and trace alcohol are shown as scholarly differences.

  • · Verdict changed

    Dishoom: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the lamb, chicken and turkey, which Dishoom says come from Halal-certified suppliers. Stunning is noted (HFA accepts it, HMC does not), and its bacon and sausages are named Haram.

  • · Verdict changed

    Banana Tree: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the All Day menu, whose meat Banana Tree says is Halal at all 21 locations. The Greenwich Breakfast menu, which it says is not Halal, is named as one to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Chopstix: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal: Chopstix publishes a Halal Friendly List certificate rating all UK branches 'Fully Halal', valid from 26 March 2026.

  • · Verdict changed

    Oodles Wok: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal: Oodles Wok describes itself as '100% Halal' across its restaurants in the UK, UAE, Canada and Qatar. It names no certifier.

  • · Verdict changed

    GDK: Halal if verified → Market-dependent

    Moved to Market-dependent: the UK and Irish kebab meat is Halal on current IFC Global and HMB certificates, while the only US certificate GDK links expired in January 2025, so the US meat is named as one to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Crimson Coward: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal: Crimson Coward says it is 100% Halal-certified at all 20 US locations and that every menu item is Halal.

  • · Verdict changed

    Houston TX Hot Chicken: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the chicken, which HHC says is Halal-certified.

  • · Verdict changed

    Mary Brown's: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal at the stores Mary Brown's store locator labels Halal (181 of 305 on 7 October 2026). Unlabelled stores, including all of Atlantic Canada, are named as ones to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Red Rooster: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the chicken, chips and signature gravy, which Red Rooster says are Halal-certified. Its restaurants are not certified because of possible cross-contamination, and the page says so.

  • · Verdict changed

    Oporto: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the chicken products Oporto says are Halal-certified by its suppliers. Its stores are not certified because of possible cross-contamination, and the page says so.

  • · Verdict changed

    Harvey's: Halal if verified → Haram

    Moved to Haram (not Halal) for Harvey's beef and chicken: Harvey's says they are not Halal-certified. The Veggie Burger and vegetarian gravy are named as meat-free options.

  • · Verdict changed

    Angus Steakhouse: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the Halal menu Angus Steakhouse says it offers, for those who accept stunning: its cattle are captive-bolt stunned, which HMC rejects, and the supplier certificates it links have passed their printed dates; both are shown on the page.

  • · Verdict changed

    Fogo de Chão: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the lamb and Australian Wagyu, which Fogo de Chão says are Halal, with the lamb chops ordered without their white wine marinade. Other cuts carry no Halal claim and are named as ones to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Poulet Rouge: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the chicken, which Poulet Rouge says comes from Halal-certified suppliers at all its locations.

  • · Verdict changed

    CAVA (restaurant): Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the braised lamb, which CAVA has said is certified Halal, and the falafel and vegetable builds. The spicy lamb meatballs (not certified, per CAVA) and the chicken and steak (no Halal claim) are named as ones to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Burger & Beyond: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the chicken at every site, which Burger & Beyond says is all Halal, and the beef at Soho. Beef at other sites is named as one to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Bleecker: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal for the beef at the five sites Bleecker names (Westfield, Baker Street, Soho, Victoria, Camden), for those who accept stunning. Its other sites' beef, which it says is not Halal, and its bacon are named as ones to skip.

  • · Verdict changed

    Shazans: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal on the HFA standard: Shazans meat and poultry are hand-slaughtered by a Muslim with the tasmiyah under HFA or equivalent certification. The animals are stunned, which HMC does not accept, and the page says so.

  • · Verdict changed

    Eggstatic: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal: Eggstatic describes itself as 'Halal Breakfast & Brunch Restaurants Across Canada'. It names no certifier.

  • · Verdict changed

    HelloFresh: Halal if verified → Haram

    Moved to Haram (not Halal) for HelloFresh meat: HelloFresh UK and Australia say they can't guarantee a Halal meal plan, and HelloFresh Canada has no Halal box. Vegetarian recipes are named as the option.

  • · Verdict changed

    Gousto: Halal if verified → Haram

    Moved to Haram (not Halal) for Gousto meat: Gousto says it doesn't specifically source Halal-certified ingredients, meat included. Meat-free recipes are named as the option.

  • · Verdict changed

    Simmer Eats: Halal if verified → Halal

    Moved to Halal: Simmer Eats says all of its meals are Halal. It names no certifier.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Nando's

    The UK answer said Halal if verified. Nando’s UK publishes the branches that serve only certified Halal chicken and handle no pork, so the UK answer is now Halal at those listed branches, with a note that the chicken is pre-stunned. Other UK branches are not Halal.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Magnum

    The UK answer said Halal if verified. The GMWA Food Guide, to which Magnum sends its product information, lists all 47 UK Magnum products as permissible, so the UK answer is now Halal on that view, as on the Wall’s page. Most contain whey that may involve animal rennet; Vegan Magnum, BonBons and the Double Salted Caramel pint declare none.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Oreos

    The UK and EU answers said Halal if verified. Oreo UK says European Oreos are not Halal-certified but nothing in them makes them unsuitable for a Muslim diet, except five named products, so the UK and EU answers are now Halal with those five excluded. A new UAE and Jordan answer (Halal) cites both governments’ January 2023 statements.

  • · Evidence corrected

    Burger King

    The UK answer said Halal if verified. Burger King UK says “We do not serve halal products”, so the UK answer is now Haram for its beef and chicken, as on the Greggs page. Malaysia stays Halal; the US stays Halal if verified.

Related