How to verify
- Read the ingredients: which meats, which fat, and what stock.
- Ask the maker whether the meat, suet and stock come from Halal-slaughtered animals, or buy haggis with a Halal mark.
- Home-made haggis with Halal meat, suet and stock is Halal.
- Keep whisky sauces off, and check vegetarian haggis for E471.
Quick checks
- Read the meat, fat and stock; each must come from Halal slaughter.
- Whisky cream sauces contain alcohol; leave them off.
- Vegetarian haggis: check the E471 in the margarine.
What decides the answer
-
Meat, suet and stock from Halal-slaughtered animals
Halal -
Meat or stock from animals not slaughtered Halal
Not Halal -
Any pork ingredient
Haram -
Whisky sauce: contains alcohol; leave it off
-
Vegetarian haggis: no meat; check the E471 source
Why this ruling
Haggis is Scotland's national dish. Traditionally it is sheep's pluck (heart, liver and lungs) minced with onion, oatmeal, suet, seasonings and stock, cooked in the animal's stomach, though an artificial casing is now common.[5] Nothing in that recipe is pork. What decides the Halal answer is whether the meat, the suet and the stock came from Halal-slaughtered animals.
Why slaughter is the question
Qur'an 5:3 forbids carrion, blood and swine, except what you have slaughtered.[6] Sheep and cattle are permissible animals, and their offal is too when the animal was slaughtered Halal. So a haggis made entirely from Halal-slaughtered lamb, beef, offal, suet and stock is Halal, whether or not it carries a printed mark. One made with meat or stock from conventionally slaughtered animals is not.
What commercial haggis contains
Recipes vary by maker, so read the label. Macsween of Edinburgh's lines show how much:
| Product | Ingredients (per Macsween) |
|---|---|
| Traditional Haggis | Lamb, beef, oats, stock, onion, salt, pepper, spices; no liver[1] |
| HUH Haggis | Lungs, beef, oats, stock, onion, salt, pepper, spices[2] |
| Vegetarian Haggis | Oats, vegetable margarine (with E471), beans, lentils, vegetables, seeds, spices[3] |
None of these lists pork. Each meat line lists stock, which has its own source: ask what it is made from.
What to check
| Part | What to check |
|---|---|
| Meat and offal | Halal slaughter of the lamb, beef or sheep |
| Suet or fat | Halal slaughter, if listed |
| Stock | What it is made from |
| Casing | Natural (animal) or artificial |
| Sauce | Whisky or wine |
Burns Night and whisky sauce
Haggis is eaten on 25 January for the poet Robert Burns, with neeps and tatties (mashed swede and potatoes). A whisky sauce often comes with it: Macsween's Whisky Cream Sauce lists white wine and whisky.[4] Leave the sauce off, and see whisky and wine.
Vegetarian haggis
Vegetarian haggis avoids the meat question. Macsween's lists vegetable margarine made with the emulsifier E471, which can come from plant or animal fat.[3] Ask the maker, or see E471.
Making it Halal
A Halal butcher can make haggis with Halal-slaughtered offal or lamb and beef, Halal suet and a Halal stock, and it is easy to make at home the same way. Serve it with a cream or pepper sauce in place of whisky.
For the other traditional Scottish and British dishes, see black pudding, lamb, beef and the Scotland guide.
Frequently asked questions
Is haggis Halal?
Does haggis contain pork?
Does haggis have to carry a Halal label?
Does haggis contain whisky?
Is vegetarian haggis Halal?
Sources
Named Islamic, certifier, manufacturer, and regulatory sources used on this page. Inline markers like [1] jump here. Retrieval dates show when we last checked the live URL. Editorial methodology.
Islamic / scriptural
Manufacturer / product
-
Macsween of Edinburgh Retrieved
Ingredients: lamb, beef, oats, stock, onion, salt, pepper, spices. Says the haggis contains no liver.
-
Macsween of Edinburgh Retrieved
Ingredients: lungs, beef, oats, stock, onion, salt, pepper, spices.
-
Delicious Every Day Vegetarian Haggis
Macsween of Edinburgh Retrieved
Ingredients include oats, vegetable margarine (with emulsifier E471), black kidney beans, carrot, swede, mushrooms, red lentils, onions, seeds and spices.
-
Macsween of Edinburgh Retrieved
Ingredients: water, white wine, whipping cream, double cream, onion, whisky, mushroom stock, cornflour.
Context / background
-
Wikipedia Retrieved
Traditional composition: sheep's pluck (heart, liver, lungs) with onion, oatmeal, suet, seasonings and stock, traditionally in the stomach, now often an artificial casing.
